In Mark John Mayo v Elizabeth Anne Stanbrook Evans & Anor [2026] EWHC 2797 (KB), Master Dagnall observed that costs incurred but unpaid may still be recoverable. A successful party’s failure to pay its solicitors does not necessarily mean the costs were never incurred. The point arose when a litigant in person argued that unpaid costs were never due, and it gives receiving parties a ready answer to a common challenge.
Background
The underlying County Court litigation between Mark John Mayo and the two Defendants appeared to be of a property nature. It produced three costs orders made by HHJ Mitchell against the First Defendant: £1,750 on 21 March 2025, £2,112 on 29 October 2025 and £1,636.80 payable by 14 January 2026. Together they totalled £5,498.80. All parties appeared before Master Dagnall as litigants in person.
The First Defendant sought to appeal orders made in October 2025, and HHJ Blohm KC refused to stay the costs order of 29 October 2025. There was no appeal against the March 2025 order. The matter came before Master Dagnall on the First Defendant’s application concerning enforcement of the costs orders. That enforcement procedure is not covered here.
Costs Issues Before the Court
Alongside her application, the First Defendant attacked the costs orders themselves. She argued that they were unjust because the Claimant had not paid his solicitors and because the costs schedules contained mathematical discrepancies. Master Dagnall had to consider how far he could entertain that attack, and he responded to the specific argument that costs not shown to have been paid were never due. He did not finally decide either question.
The Parties’ Positions
The First Defendant said she had not been provided with the N260 costs schedule for the March 2025 order, a matter heavily in dispute between the parties, and that she could not appeal without it. Her wider contention was that all the orders were unjust or fraudulent, because relevant costs had not been paid by Mr Mayo to his solicitors and the schedules contained obvious mathematical discrepancies.
The Court’s Decision
Master Dagnall’s starting point was that the First Defendant was possibly operating under a number of misconceptions as to the law, a view he expressed at first sight and without finally deciding it [7]. The first was that an order of the court is binding unless or until set aside, either by the court that made it or on appeal. He cited R (on the application of Majera) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2021] UKSC 46 for that principle [7].
The second was that, although the rules provide for an N260 to be provided within certain periods of time, the court can always waive that requirement under its general discretionary power in CPR 3.10. It can then proceed as it considers just, in accordance with the overriding objective in CPR 1.1 [8].
The third concerned the route for challenge. An appeal may be brought under CPR 52.21(3) on the basis that the decision below was wrong, or unjust because of a serious procedural or other irregularity [9]. Complaints such as not having received a relevant document, or not having been heard, are potential grounds of appeal, but whether they suffice is for the appeal court [10]. A party lacking documents may seek them from the court file or ask the appeal court for disclosure [11].
On that footing, Master Dagnall declined to proceed on the basis that the County Court’s costs orders were a nullity. He said: “I am not the appeal court.” Appeals from the costs orders lay to the Bristol District Registry, where they are dealt with by High Court Judges or those sitting as Deputy High Court Judges, and not by Masters [12].
The point specific to unpaid costs arose because the First Defendant contended that Mr Mayo had not demonstrated that he had actually paid particular solicitors’ costs [48]. Master Dagnall accepted that the fact that asserted costs have not been paid may indicate that they were never actually due. He added, however, that “it does not necessarily follow from their not having been paid that they have not been incurred” [48].
The distinction drawn was between costs being paid and costs being incurred. If costs have been incurred by a successful party, the Master said, that may very well entitle that party to an outcome that the losing side should pay them, particularly since that then enables the successful party to pay its own solicitors [48]. Costs incurred but unpaid are not, on this reasoning, automatically irrecoverable.
The observation was carefully limited. Master Dagnall said he drew the First Defendant’s attention to it only because it was a matter on which she might wish to obtain legal advice [48]. It was not a decision on the recoverability of any item in the Claimant’s schedules, and the words “may very well” stop short of a rule that incurred costs are always recoverable.
The Master also drew attention to the scale of the dispute. He described the costs orders as relatively small in court terms, and in particular High Court terms. He suggested that spending a large amount of time, costs and resource on relatively low-level costs orders may well generate much greater liabilities than those in dispute [46]. He referred the parties to alternative dispute resolution and to the Supreme Court’s statement that court orders are there to be obeyed [46].
He added that disliking a decision does not necessarily mean it is so wrong that it should be set aside. A party should think carefully before spending more time, resource and emotional energy challenging it, though the right to seek permission to appeal remains [47]. On the schedule dispute, he included a suggestion, not an order, that the March 2025 schedule be sent or resent to the First Defendant [44] and [49].
Practical Implications
This is a first instance decision of a Master, and the observation on unpaid costs was expressly not a ruling. It nonetheless gives receiving parties a short answer to a familiar argument, particularly from litigants in person: non-payment may indicate that the costs were never due, but it does not necessarily follow that they were not incurred [48].
Receiving parties facing the argument should be ready to show the retainer and the liability to their solicitors, rather than proof of payment. Paying parties who wish to run it should frame non-payment as evidence that the costs were never due, supported by material going beyond the bare fact that invoices remain unpaid.
Any such challenge must be taken in the right forum. A costs order binds until set aside by the court that made it or on appeal [7], and the Master dealing with the separate application here declined to treat it as a nullity [12]. Arguments about costs incurred but unpaid, or about arithmetic in a schedule, belong before the court below or the appeal court.
Where the sums are modest, both sides should weigh the Master’s warning that prolonged challenges may generate liabilities greater than those in dispute [46]. Supplying or requesting the underlying costs schedule early may also narrow the issues [44].
▶ Watch the case summary
Enforcement Of Costs Orders Not Stayed Merely Because Related Proceedings Remain on Appeal
Applications To Stay Enforcement Of Interim Costs Orders | The Principles
Party Penalised For Failure To File A Costs Schedule In Advance Of Hearing
Wasted Costs Applications | The Practical Necessity Of A Costs Schedule
Related service: costs advocacy at detailed assessments and costs hearings.






















![JBX v Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust (Costs) [2026] EWHC 2525 (KB)](https://tmclegal.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/image_3c266abd.webp)


