Interest On Costs Runs From The Order Date Absent A Different Order | Court Refuses Deferral Pending A Detailed Bill

Under the incipitur rule, interest on costs runs from the date of the costs order on the sum eventually found due, so uncertainty about the figure claimed is, in the majority of cases, no reason to defer. A paying party seeking clarity can accelerate detailed assessment under CPR 47.8.

close-up of an analogue clock face with a calendar date visible behind it
In Cleveland Potash Ltd v Drummond & Ors [2026] EWHC 2781 (BP), Master Kaye, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, refused the paying parties’ application to defer the date from which interest accrued on a standard basis costs order until they had more detail of the costs. Interest ran at 8% from the date of the order on the sums eventually found due. Under the incipitur rule, interest on costs runs from the date of the costs order unless the court orders otherwise, and accrues only on the sum eventually found due, so uncertainty about the figure claimed is, in the majority of cases, no reason to defer. Where an interim payment has been carefully calibrated to reflect the paying party’s risks, there will rarely be a good reason to postpone accrual. A paying party wanting clarity can accelerate detailed assessment under CPR 47.8.

[191] The entitlement to interest on costs runs from the date on which the order for costs is made and not from the date on which the quantum of the costs is determined unless the court makes a different order (the incipitur rule). The logic for this is that the costs order is a judgment debt and interest would accrue from the date of the judgment in the usual course. If the court had the time and resources to determine the quantum of the costs and/or carry out the detailed assessment at the time at which the order was made it would. [192] However, interest will only ever accrue on the sum that is eventually found due not the sum sought. Consequently, the absence of clarity on the precise figure claimed at the time the costs order is made or an interim payment on account is ordered is nothing to the point in the majority of cases.

Citations

Involnert Management Inc v Aprilgrange Limited & Ors [2015] EWHC 2834 (Comm) Relied on by the respondents for the passage in which Leggatt LJ did not think it just for interest at the judgment rate to run on further sums before the paying party had been provided with a detailed statement of the costs claimed.

Excalibur Ventures LLC v Texas Keystone Inc [2015] EWHC 566 (Comm) Cited for the proposition that a reasonable sum on account is an estimate of the likely level of recovery, involving an element of uncertainty and not based on an irreducible minimum, and that the process of determining a reasonable sum can take into account the risk of the sum sought being too high and/or the risk of the paying party having difficulties in recovering any sum overpaid.

Key Points

  • Interest on costs runs from the date of the costs order rather than the date quantum is determined, unless the court makes a different order, because the costs order is a judgment debt (the incipitur rule). [191]
  • Because interest accrues only on the sum eventually found due, uncertainty about the figure claimed when a costs order or interim payment is made is, in the majority of cases, no reason to defer interest. [192, 199]
  • The court may order interest on costs to run from an earlier date or defer it under CPR 40.8(2) and CPR 44.2(6)(g), but must be satisfied there is a good reason, exercising its broad discretion consistently with the overriding objective. [193, 198]
  • Particularly where the interim payment has been carefully calibrated to reflect the risks identified by the paying party, there will rarely be a good reason to postpone the accrual of interest from the date of the order. [194]
  • A paying party that wants more clarity about the costs claimed can accelerate assessment by forcing the receiving party to produce a bill of costs and commence detailed assessment under CPR 47.8. [200]

[193] “Pursuant to CPR 40.8(2) and CPR 44.2(6)(g) the court may order that interest on costs starts to run from a date earlier than the date of any costs order or may defer the date on which the liability for interest starts to accrue. [194] Particularly where, as here, the interim payment has been carefully calibrated to ensure that it is a reasonable sum taking into account the risks identified by the paying party and balancing that against the interest of the receiving party there will rarely be a good reason to postpone or defer the accrual of interest from the date of the order.”

Key Findings In The Case

  • The respondents’ application to defer interest on costs until three months after the order, or a month after service of the detailed bill, was refused. [189, 201]
  • Interest was to run at 8% in the usual way from the date of the costs order on the sums eventually found due to CPL. [201]
  • The argument based on Involnert, that interest should not run before the paying party had a detailed statement of the costs, did not tip the balance, as it was at odds with the respondents’ submissions on the interim payment. [196, 197, 198]
  • The £550,000 interim payment left substantial headroom for concerns about recoverability and quantum, and its payment would reduce the respondents’ risk on ongoing interest. [187, 194, 199]
  • No submission questioned CPL’s ability to repay any overpayment including interest, and it was unclear why deferral was sought or needed. [195]

[199] “Rs will only ever pay interest on the sums eventually found due. They maintain the costs are excessive. If they are right that the costs will be substantially reduced on assessment and even below the interim payment on account, that will affect any interest they may have to pay in due course. The interim payment, if paid, will reduce their risk in relation to ongoing interest on either basis. [200] If Rs consider that they need more clarity, they will be in a position to accelerate the costs assessment process and force CPL to produce a bill of costs and commence a detailed assessment pursuant to CPR 47.8 in due course should they wish to do so.”

In Cleveland Potash Ltd v Drummond & Ors [2026] EWHC 2781 (BP), the High Court refused to defer interest on costs until the paying parties had a detailed breakdown of the costs claimed. Interest accrues only on sums eventually found due, and a carefully calibrated interim payment had been ordered, so deferral was not justified. Paying parties seeking to postpone interest will need a good reason beyond the absence of a detailed bill.

Background

The claim arose from a referral by the Secretary of State to the court under the 1966 Act, by which CPL sought rights over the respondents’ interests to work polyhalite. Following a trial of certain valuation and proprietary issues, Master Kaye, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, determined the consequential matters on paper, including costs.

The respondents (Rs) accepted that CPL was the more successful party. CPL obtained an order that Rs pay its costs on the standard basis, subject to detailed assessment if not agreed [107]. Its Part 36 offer did not attract the enhanced consequences [137]. CPL put its costs, excluding the Preliminary Issue costs, at £1,204,160.86 [153], and the court ordered an interim payment on account of £550,000 [186].

Costs Issues Before the Court

The issue addressed here was whether the date from which interest accrues on the costs order should be postponed. Rs sought an order deferring accrual until after they had received more detail about the costs, either three months from the order or a month after the detailed bill of costs for detailed assessment had been served [189]. The question was decided after, and alongside, the court’s determination of the interim payment.

The Parties’ Positions

Rs relied on Involnert Management Inc v Aprilgrange Limited & Ors [2015] EWHC 2834 (Comm), in which Leggatt LJ did not think it just for interest on further sums the claimant was ultimately found liable to pay to begin to run at the judgment rate before the claimant had been provided with a detailed statement of the costs claimed [196].

Rs submitted that the same applied here, because CPL had not provided an adequate breakdown of the work to enable them to take an informed view of the amount of their liability [197]. They also maintained that the costs claimed were excessive [199].

The Court’s Decision

Master Kaye began with the source of the entitlement. Interest on a costs order derives from sections 17 and 18 of the Judgments Act 1838, CPR 40.8 and CPR 44.2(6)(g). For these purposes the receiving party is treated as the judgment creditor and the paying party as the judgment debtor [190].

Under the incipitur rule, interest on costs runs from the date of the costs order, not the date on which quantum is determined, unless the court makes a different order [191]. The logic is that the costs order is a judgment debt. The judge explained that, if the court had the time and resources to determine quantum when making the order, it would do so.

The second strand of the reasoning was that interest only ever accrues on the sum eventually found due, not the sum sought. Accordingly, as Master Kaye put it, a lack of clarity about the precise figure when the costs order is made or an interim payment is ordered “is nothing to the point in the majority of cases” [192]. The point was put as a general rule, not as a universal one.

The court has power under CPR 40.8(2) and CPR 44.2(6)(g) to order interest to run from an earlier date or to defer it [193]. Whether to postpone or defer is an exercise of the court’s broad discretion, consistent with the overriding objective, having regard to the particular circumstances, and the court must be satisfied that there is a good reason for doing so [198].

The interim payment was central. Master Kaye said that, particularly where the interim payment has been carefully calibrated as a reasonable sum, taking account of the paying party’s risks and balancing them against the receiving party’s interest, “there will rarely be a good reason to postpone or defer the accrual of interest from the date of the order” [194]. Here, £550,000 left substantial headroom for the concerns about recoverability and quantum [187].

CPL was a substantial entity, and none of the submissions were concerned with its ability to repay any overpayment, which would include interest. Master Kaye said it was and remained unclear why, in those circumstances, any deferral was sought or needed in this case [195].

The argument based on Involnert did not succeed. The judge observed that Rs’ complaint about an inadequate breakdown seemed at odds with the submissions they had been able to make on the interim payment [197]. CPL’s schedule was broken into 11 phases [155]. It was not a detailed bill, nor as detailed as a costs budget, and gave no detail of the work done, yet Rs were well able to critique it and did so [156].

Rs were also protected in two further ways. They would only ever pay interest on the sums eventually found due, so a substantial reduction on assessment, even below the interim payment, would reduce any interest payable; payment of the interim sum would also reduce their risk on ongoing interest [199]. If they needed more clarity, they could force CPL to produce a bill and commence detailed assessment under CPR 47.8 [200].

None of the points raised by Rs tipped the balance [198]. The court found no proper basis to defer or postpone post-judgment interest, and did not consider it unjust that interest should run at 8% in the usual way from the date of the costs order on the sums eventually found due to CPL [201].

Practical Implications

This is a first instance decision applying settled principle rather than making new law. Its value lies in the application: the paying parties could not defer interest on costs because the receiving party had served a phased schedule rather than a detailed bill, where they had been able to critique that schedule when arguing the interim payment.

Paying parties seeking deferral should identify a specific good reason, beyond the absence of a detailed bill. Arguments that the costs are excessive are better deployed in fixing the interim payment, since interest follows only the sums eventually found due. Where clarity is the real concern, the route the court identified is CPR 47.8, not an order postponing interest.

Receiving parties resisting deferral should link the interest argument to the interim payment: a sum calibrated with headroom for the paying party’s concerns means that postponement will rarely be justified. Evidence that the receiving party can repay any overpayment will assist. Where Involnert is relied on, the contrast with the paying party’s own detailed interim payment submissions is the point to press.

▶ Watch the case summary

When Does Interest On Costs Become “Due” For The Purpose Of s24(2) Limitation Act 1980?

CPR 44.2(6)(g) | Pre Judgment Interest On Costs Under | A General Rule?

Payments On Account In Budgeted Cases And Pre Judgment Interest On Costs

CPR 47.8 | Master Brown Orders Unless Order For Commencement | CPR 47.7 Held To Be Mandatory

CPR 44.2(8) | Payments On Account In Civil Litigation