Preliminary Issue Costs Order Is Bookended By Its Own Dates | Earlier Costs Of That Issue Stay In The Claim Absent A Broader Order

A costs order limited to the costs of a preliminary issue is bookended by its own dates; costs referable to the same subject matter incurred before the order creating that issue may fall to be treated as general claim costs. A party wanting broader exclusion should raise it before the preliminary issue costs order is made.

Beautiful hand shaped bookends with books on shelf indoors
In Cleveland Potash Ltd v Drummond & Ors [2026] EWHC 2781 (BP), Master Kaye, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, held that an order requiring the applicant to pay the respondents’ costs of a lost preliminary issue did not stop the applicant recovering its general costs of the proceedings. That order was limited to the period from the order creating the issue to its determination. Absent some broader order, costs referable to the same issue incurred before the preliminary issue was ordered seemed to fall to be treated as claim costs. Until that date the issue was one of many in dispute, and the order had deliberately bookended its period. Any dispute over attribution is for detailed assessment. In the judge’s view, a respondent wanting earlier costs of the issue excluded should raise that at the end of the preliminary issue, before the costs order on it is made.

[35] The Preliminary Issue Order precludes CPL from seeking to recover any costs it has incurred in relation to the Preliminary Issue during the period specified by the Preliminary Issue Order. It is an order which has both temporal limits and issues-based effect. It does not preclude CPL from seeking to recover its costs relating to the proceedings generally during that same period. The liability for those costs falls to be determined as part of this determination.

Citations

Re Gibson’s Settlement [1981] Ch 179 Cited as an example of the conventional general principle that pre-action costs are recoverable on a detailed assessment, without special wording in the costs order.

Budgen v Andrew Gardner Partnership [2002] EWCA Civ 1125 One of the authorities the parties referred to on identifying the successful party and whether to depart from the general rule on costs.

Fox v Foundation Piling Limited [2011] EWCA Civ 790 Referred to by the parties, at Jackson LJ’s judgment, on identifying the successful party and whether to depart from the general rule on costs.

Jockey Club Racecourse Ltd v Willmott Dixon Construction Ltd [2016] EWHC 167 (TCC) Cited for the proposition that a Part 36 offer must involve a measure of give and take but need not be particularly generous to be a commercial offer of settlement.

Excalibur Ventures LLC v Texas Keystone Inc [2015] EWHC 566 (Comm) Cited for the approach that a reasonable sum on account of costs is an estimate of likely recovery, involving uncertainty, and is not based on an irreducible minimum.

Involnert Management Inc v Aprilgrange Limited & Ors [2015] EWHC 2834 (Comm) Relied on by the respondents in seeking deferral of interest on costs until a detailed statement of costs was provided; the court declined to defer interest on the facts.

Key Points

  • A costs order limited to the costs of a preliminary issue within specified dates has both temporal and issues-based effect: it bars the paying party from recovering its preliminary issue costs in that period but not its general costs of the proceedings for the same period. [35]
  • Whether particular costs in the preliminary issue period are referable to the claim or to the preliminary issue is not a question for the incidence of costs but one to be raised on detailed assessment. [36, 37]
  • Absent some broader order, costs referable to the subject matter of a preliminary issue that were incurred before the order creating it may fall to be treated as general costs of the claim, since until that order the issue was one of many in dispute. [44, 47]
  • A party wishing to extend a preliminary issue costs order backwards, or to exclude earlier costs of the issue from the other side’s recovery, should in the court’s view raise that before the preliminary issue costs order is made. [48]
  • A general costs order needs no temporal limit or special wording for pre-action costs to be recoverable on detailed assessment, where the line between recoverable and irrecoverable costs is generally drawn. [13, 15]

[44] “But perhaps more simply the Preliminary Issue Order did not award the costs of the Preliminary Issue to Rs on an open-ended basis but deliberately bookended the costs order as covering a specified period. Until 17 October 2023 there was no Preliminary Issue. Prior to that date the Reservation issue had existed since at least the late 1960s and had never been determined. It was only from 17 October 2023 that the costs relating to what had then become the Preliminary Issue ceased to be part of the generic issues to be determined by the proceedings and the generic costs of the issues in dispute.”

Key Findings In The Case

  • The Preliminary Issue Order did not address the costs of the Referral or the proceedings generally and was properly limited by a start date of 17 October 2023, when the Order for a Preliminary Issue was made. [34]
  • The Preliminary Issue and its costs order had no bearing on the appropriate costs order for 17 October 2023 to 2 July 2024, only on the amount recoverable inter partes. [37]
  • Costs referable to the Reservation before 17 October 2023 were not excluded in principle from the costs of the proceedings; they formed part of the whole and could not be disentangled without arbitrariness. [38, 42]
  • Any argument to fold pre-17 October 2023 Reservation costs into the preliminary issue costs, or to exclude them, appeared to be one for the judge making the Preliminary Issue Order; the consequentials court would not vary that order. [47, 48]
  • The costs reserved by the Directions Order were treated as costs in the case and fell within CPL’s costs order. [50, 107]
  • The Preliminary Issue did not support no order for costs; the entanglement of issues instead emphasised caution about a percentage or issues-based order. [49]

[48] “If Rs had wanted to argue that any costs relating to the Reservation issue should be incorporated into the costs of the Preliminary Issue and/or that CPL were to be precluded from recovering any costs relating to the Reservation issue prior to 17 October 2023 it appears to me that that was a costs issue for the Preliminary Issue and should have been raised with the learned judge before the Preliminary Issue Order was made. However, that would only have raised the difficulty Rs themselves rely on now, of the impossibility of untangling the issues prior to the Order for the Preliminary Issue.”

In Cleveland Potash Ltd v Drummond & Ors [2026] EWHC 2781 (BP), the court held that a preliminary issue costs order running from the date of the order creating the preliminary issue did not carve earlier costs of the same subject matter out of the general costs of the claim. For respondents who win a preliminary issue, the time to argue for a wider order is at that stage, not after trial.

Background

The claim arose from a referral by the Secretary of State under the 1966 Act, by which Cleveland Potash Ltd (CPL) sought rights from the respondents (Rs) to continue working polyhalite. The claim as issued included a declaration that the first respondent (R1) did not own the rights she claimed by the Reservation [31].

On 20 June 2023 Master Brightwell made the Directions Order, with costs reserved. On 17 October 2023 he ordered a Preliminary Issue on the Reservation, with costs in the Preliminary Issue [16]. CPL lost. The Preliminary Issue Order required CPL to pay Rs’ costs incurred between 17 October 2023 and 2 July 2024 [16]. CPL later succeeded at trial on all issues except the Bocardo issue [103].

Costs Issues Before the Court

Rs accepted that CPL were the more successful party [18]. The questions were whether the Preliminary Issue Order excluded from CPL’s general costs any costs referable to the Reservation issue, both within the preliminary issue period and before it; whether the reserved costs of the Directions Order were recoverable; and whether the Preliminary Issue supported no order for costs up to April or July 2024 [29, 32, 33].

The Parties’ Positions

R1 submitted that costs relating to the Reservation issue should not be recoverable by CPL, whether they related specifically to the Preliminary Issue or were attributable to the Reservation issue before 17 October 2023 [32]. She argued that the Directions Order costs should be irrecoverable for the same reason [33]. Rs also contended that earlier Reservation costs should count as a conduct factor supporting no order for costs [39]. R2 adopted R1’s submissions [3, 20].

The Court’s Decision

Master Kaye began with the scope of the existing order. The Preliminary Issue Order did not address the costs of the Referral or of the proceedings more generally. It was properly limited to the costs of the Preliminary Issue, using as its start date the day the Order for a Preliminary Issue was made [34].

She described it as “an order which has both temporal limits and issues-based effect”. It precluded CPL from recovering costs incurred in relation to the Preliminary Issue during the specified period. It did not preclude CPL from recovering its costs of the proceedings generally during that same period [35].

Whether any costs in that period were referable to the claim rather than the Preliminary Issue was not a matter for the incidence of costs. Rs could challenge recovery on detailed assessment if they considered particular costs properly attributable to the Preliminary Issue [36]. The Preliminary Issue therefore bore only on the amount recoverable inter partes, not on the appropriate order, and gave no support to Rs’ proposed no order for costs [37].

The harder question concerned costs referable to the Reservation before 17 October 2023. Those seemed to the judge to fall to be treated as costs of the claim generically [38]. Until that date the Reservation was simply one of many issues in dispute. It was inextricably linked to the negotiations over the terms on which CPL would acquire the disputed rights [40].

The judge was not persuaded that those costs could or should be excluded in principle, as they formed part of the whole. She agreed with Rs that it would in any event be impossible to disentangle them, and that any attempt would be arbitrary [42]. The point might have had more force had the Reservation been the issue, with everything else settled after the Preliminary Issue [43].

More simply, the Preliminary Issue Order did not award the costs on an open-ended basis but “deliberately bookended the costs order as covering a specified period” [44]. Until 17 October 2023 there was no Preliminary Issue. There was obvious sense in limiting the costs to the period from that order until determination [45].

It was not for the judge to vary the Preliminary Issue Order. Absent some broader order, the earlier Reservation costs seemed to her simply part of the costs of the proceedings. Any grey area around 17 October 2023 itself appeared resolved, at least in part, by the Order for the Preliminary Issue reserving the costs relating to that order [47].

If Rs had wanted the earlier costs folded into the preliminary issue costs, or excluded from CPL’s recovery, that appeared to the judge to be a point that “should have been raised with the learned judge before the Preliminary Issue Order was made”. She added that it would only have raised the same difficulty of untangling the issues [48].

The Preliminary Issue therefore gave no support for no order for costs and instead counselled caution about a percentage or issues-based order [49]. The reserved Directions Order costs were costs in the case. That order was a quintessential case management decision that would always have been necessary; it is distinguished from the Order for a Preliminary Issue, which reserved costs to the Preliminary Issue [50].

Practical Implications

This is a first instance decision, but its reasoning on preliminary issue costs is readily transferable. The boundary of such an order is set by its own terms. Where it runs from the order creating the preliminary issue, earlier costs of the same subject matter are, absent a broader order, likely to be treated as general costs of the claim [44, 47].

Respondents who win a preliminary issue should decide at the preliminary issue costs hearing whether to seek a wider order. That might be an earlier start date, or a provision excluding earlier costs of the issue from the other side’s general recovery. The judge indicated that this was the proper forum [48]. Expect the entanglement objection, and come with evidence identifying discrete pre-order work.

Receiving parties need no special wording to recover pre-action costs under a general order [13, 15]. Their bill should still separate costs within the preliminary issue period, since attribution disputes go to detailed assessment rather than the incidence of costs [36]. Reserved costs of a first directions hearing that led to the preliminary issue may be treated as costs in the case [50].

▶ Watch the case summary

 

Costs of determining a preliminary issue

Costs Exceptionally Reserved On Preliminary Issue Due To Potential Set-Off Against Arbitration Awards

CPR 44.2(6)(f) | Costs In The Case Where Interwoven Issues And No Clear Winner Precludes Issue-Based Or Percentage Orders

Issues Based And Proportional Costs Orders: When Should They Be Made?

Dos Santos Principles Considered | Trial Outcome Remains Relevant To Reserved Costs