The Justice Committee’s report, Access to Justice: Access to Legal Services, recommends an extension of qualified one-way costs shifting and a review of fixed recoverable costs. According to the Law Society Gazette, the 138-page report was published on 19 November 2026 and also calls for a national legal service akin to NHS 111. The Gazette reports that the report concludes an inquiry which began in July 2025.
The Detail
The report says that reform of civil litigation funding should include an extension of qualified one-way costs shifting, a review of fixed recoverable costs, immediate legislation to reverse the effects of the PACCAR judgment, statutory regulation of third-party litigation funding and protection of opt-out collective actions.
On the case for wider protection, the report states: “Qualified one-way costs shifting is vital for enabling individuals to pursue claims without facing the full deterrent effect of adverse costs.” It adds: “There may be other categories of civil litigation where qualified one way costs shifting would be beneficial.”
The report identifies a difficulty with each regime as it stands: “Fixed recoverable costs can make some claims uneconomic, while the limited scope of qualified one-way costs shifting leaves claimants in other areas exposed to potentially prohibitive adverse costs.”
The committee also recommends a review of the “fundamental dishonesty rules within qualified one-way costs shifting, including whether the present framework provides appropriate and equivalent safeguards against unreasonable conduct by defendants” [245-250].
On funding, the Gazette reports that the committee proposes extra ringfenced funding through a portfolio of mechanisms. According to the Gazette, these include interest on client account cash and targeted levies on litigation funding profits and high-value litigation.
Why It Matters
The report sets out recommendations for reform rather than amendments to the rules. Claimant solicitors should continue to advise clients on adverse costs exposure under the present regime. Defendants who intend to allege fundamental dishonesty should note the committee’s interest in safeguards against unreasonable conduct by defendants, which could attract closer scrutiny if the recommended review goes ahead.
Practitioners working under fixed recoverable costs may wish to record examples of claims that the regime has made uneconomic, as that evidence could inform any review. Claimant representatives responding to any future consultation may draw on the committee’s view of the role of qualified one-way costs shifting. Those advising funders should also follow the recommendations on PACCAR and funder regulation.
Originally reported by The Law Society Gazette.









