Adjudicator Recovers Legal Costs And Pursuit Time As Contractual Debt | Natural Justice Irrelevant | Summary Judgment Granted

Where an adjudicator’s terms entitle him to recover the full amount of his administrative, legal and other costs of pursuing unpaid invoices, that claim is a contractual debt to which alleged breaches of natural justice are irrelevant. Adjudicators with such terms and contemporaneous records may recover those sums summarily.

red stamp reading PAID
In Gerard McLean & Anor v Winchester Medical Aesthetics Limited [2026] EWHC 2941 (TCC), Her Honour Judge Kelly, sitting as a Judge of the High Court, granted an adjudicator and his practice summary judgment for his fees, his time spent pursuing payment after the decision, interest and his legal costs. The agreed terms entitled him to recover the full amount of his administrative, legal and other costs of recovering unpaid invoices, and to be paid regardless of whether his decision was enforceable. His claim was a contractual debt claim, to which alleged breaches of natural justice and excess of jurisdiction were irrelevant. Both the fees and the post-decision time were supported by contemporaneous timesheets, and the defendant advanced no positive case on what time would have been reasonable. Adjudicators with such terms, and contemporaneous records of pursuit time, may recover those sums summarily as a debt.

[44] “Further, as the Adjudicator has had to incur further fees and costs seeking payment and bringing these proceedings, he is entitled (under the terms and conditions agreed) to claim those fees as well as the reasonable professional legal fees which he has incurred. The First Claimant has provided evidence of the additional time spent between March 2026 and August 2026 when the application was issued. Again, a contemporaneous timesheet has been provided with explanation of the tasks undertaken. In my judgment, all of those were reasonable and the First Claimant is entitled to claim the 4 hours 18 minutes recorded in the sum of £1393.20 plus VAT (£1,671.84) at the agreed rate of £324 per hour in addition to the claims as set out above.”

Citations

Steve Ward Services (UK) Ltd v Davies & Davies Associates Ltd [2022] EWCA Civ 153 Cited for the principles that an adjudicator may recover fees even for an unenforceable decision and may have terms making the parties jointly and severally liable for fees and costs, and for the Court of Appeal’s holding that section 3(2)(b) of UCTA did not apply to a similar joint and several liability provision, which was reasonable in any event.

The Vinden Partnership Ltd v ORCA LGS Solutions Ltd & Stourport on Severn Care Ltd [2017] EWHC B24 (TCC) Cited for the implied obligation that an adjudicator’s fees will be reasonable, excludable only by very clear words, and for the requirement that a challenge to them be particularised with a positive case rather than putting the adjudicator to proof.

Fenice Investments Inc v Jerram Falkus Construction Ltd [2011] EWHC 1678 Cited alongside The Vinden Partnership for the same principles on the reasonableness of adjudicators’ fees and the need for a positive, particularised challenge.

Easyair Ltd v Opal Telecom Ltd [2009] EWHC 339 (Ch) Cited for the principles governing summary judgment, including that the court must not conduct a mini trial but need not take every factual assertion at face value.

Swain v Hillman [2001] 2 All ER 91 Cited, through Easyair, for the test of a realistic as opposed to a fanciful prospect of success.

ED&F Man Liquid Products v Patel [2003] EWCA Civ 472 Cited, through Easyair, for the proposition that a realistic defence carries some degree of conviction and is more than merely arguable.

Key Points

  • An adjudicator’s terms may entitle him to recover, as part of a contractual debt, the time spent and the reasonable professional legal fees incurred in pursuing payment after his decision, where they provide for recovery of the full amount of his administrative, legal and other costs of recovering unpaid invoices [13, 44].
  • Where an adjudicator’s terms provide for payment regardless of the enforceability of his decision, alleged breaches of natural justice or excess of jurisdiction go to enforcement between the parties and do not answer his contractual claim for fees [34, 38].
  • An adjudicator is under an implied obligation that his fees will be reasonable in all the circumstances; a party challenging them must particularise why and make a positive case, as putting the adjudicator to proof will not suffice [18, 41].
  • Contemporaneous timesheets explaining the tasks undertaken can support recovery of an adjudicator’s fees and post-decision pursuit time on summary judgment, absent any contrary evidence [39, 44].

[34] “In short, no. The fact (if established) that the Adjudicator had acted outside of his jurisdiction or in breach of natural justice would be relevant in respect of enforcement of that Decision against the other party to the adjudication. Here, those matters are irrelevant because this is a debt claim where the Claimants assert a contractual right to be paid. The terms and conditions agreed to by Winchester Medical are clear that the Adjudicator is entitled to charge in full and be paid regardless of whether or not his decision is enforceable. No Defence on these grounds has any prospect of success even if there was any evidence to support a breach of natural justice or excess of jurisdiction.”

Key Findings In The Case

  • The Adjudicator was entitled under the agreed terms to claim his further fees and costs of seeking payment and bringing proceedings, together with the reasonable professional legal fees he had incurred [44].
  • The further pursuit time of 4 hours 18 minutes, supported by a contemporaneous timesheet explaining the tasks, was reasonable and recoverable at the agreed £324 per hour, £1,671.84 including VAT [44].
  • The Claimants recovered their legal costs in the sums claimed, totalling £37,664.30; although contractually recoverable, they would not have been reduced in any event, being reasonably incurred and reasonable in amount [48, 49].
  • The costs were possibly higher than they might have been, which in large part appeared to result from the extra work required by the Defendant’s unmeritorious and wide-ranging submissions [49].
  • Jurisdiction and natural justice defences had no prospect of success because the claim was a contractual debt claim and the terms provided for payment regardless of enforceability [34].
  • The challenge to the hours was wholly inadequate, the Defendant having accepted that they were worked and advanced no positive case on what time would have been reasonable [41].

[18] “An adjudicator is entitled to charge for his time and recover fees even if he delivers an unenforceable decision and is entitled to stipulate those terms in terms and conditions. Similarly, chargeable time may include time spent at court, the costs of securing payment of fees, expenses and any disbursements. Adjudicators are entitled as a matter of course to have terms which make parties to an adjudication jointly and severally liable for fees and costs (see Steve Ward Services (UK) Ltd v Davies & Davies Associates Ltd [2022] EWCA Civ 153).”

In Gerard McLean & Anor v Winchester Medical Aesthetics Limited [2026] EWHC 2941 (TCC), the High Court held that an adjudicator’s terms entitled him to recover the time he spent chasing payment and his legal costs of recovery, alongside his adjudicator fees, as a contractual debt. The decision shows how recovery wording and contemporaneous records work together on summary judgment, for those drafting or resisting adjudicators’ terms.

Background

The First Claimant was nominated by RIBA to adjudicate a dispute between Winchester Medical and its contractor, Archiproject, after a construction contract was terminated. He sent both parties his terms and conditions, which they signed and returned. Winchester Medical made no objection to any of them [11], [12].

Clause 2 provided for remuneration at £324 per hour plus VAT for all time expended, including where the decision was not enforced. Clause 4(b) entitled the Adjudicator to interest at 8% above base rate on unpaid invoices and to the full amount of his administrative, legal and other costs of recovering them. Clause 8 made the parties jointly and severally liable [13].

The decision was given on 7 March 2025 and the Claimants were not paid [3]. They claimed fees to the decision of £14,113.44, time spent pursuing recovery, interest and costs [5]. They did not oppose the setting aside of a default judgment, but warned that they would apply for summary judgment on receipt of a Defence [6], [7].

Costs Issues Before the Court

Among the issues was whether the fees claimed were recoverable, including the time spent pursuing payment after the decision [22]. The court also had to decide what the Claimants should recover as their legal costs of the proceedings [48]. On a summary judgment application, the question was whether the Defendant had a realistic prospect of defending the claim. The judge stressed that her findings were to be read in that light and not as final determinations [21].

The Parties’ Positions

For the Claimants, this was a straightforward debt enforcement claim under the contract agreed between the parties [5]. The Defendant denied the whole claim. It said the terms were not fairly incorporated and were unreasonable under UCTA, that the Adjudicator had acted outside his jurisdiction and in breach of natural justice, and that his fees were unreasonable, inflated and caused by his mismanagement of the process [14].

The Defendant’s objections extended to clause 4, which entitled the Adjudicator to interest and to his legal, administrative and other costs in the event of non-payment [24].

The Court’s Decision

The terms were not in dispute: they were agreed in their entirety when Winchester Medical signed and returned them [23]. HHJ Kelly found them entirely fairly set out. Their wording was not complicated, and if the Defendant needed clarification it could and should have sought legal advice [26]. No particulars were given of the UCTA challenge, and none of the clauses objected to was an exclusion clause [29].

The judge noted that, in Steve Ward, the Court of Appeal had held section 3(2)(b) of UCTA not to apply to a similar provision making the parties jointly and severally liable regardless of the enforceability of the decision, and had held such a term reasonable in any event [29].

That contractual footing disposed of the jurisdiction and natural justice points. Those matters would be relevant to enforcement of the Decision against the other party to the adjudication. They were irrelevant here because, as the judge put it, “this is a debt claim where the Claimants assert a contractual right to be paid” [34].

In setting out the governing principles, the judge recorded, citing Steve Ward, that “chargeable time may include time spent at court, the costs of securing payment of fees, expenses and any disbursements” [18]. She also recorded, citing The Vinden Partnership and Fenice Investments, an implied obligation that an adjudicator’s fees will be reasonable. A challenge requires particulars and a positive case; putting the adjudicator to proof will not suffice [18].

On the adjudicator fees up to the decision, the hourly rate and the hours worked were held entirely reasonable and supported by contemporaneous timesheets [39]. Paragraph 17 of the Scheme required the Adjudicator to consider all submissions made to him to ascertain their relevance [40]. His uncontradicted evidence described multiple rounds of unfocused submissions and a vast number of documents [41].

Ms Sampietro Colomer accepted at the hearing that she was not really arguing that the hours on the timesheets had not been performed. Her complaint was that it was unreasonable to spend so much time on Archiproject’s emails. With no positive case as to what time would have been reasonable, that was wholly inadequate to provide a realistic basis for defending the claim [41].

Turning to post-decision work, the judge held that, having had to incur further fees and costs seeking payment and bringing proceedings, “he is entitled (under the terms and conditions agreed) to claim those fees as well as the reasonable professional legal fees which he has incurred” [44].

The additional time was supported by a contemporaneous timesheet with an explanation of the tasks undertaken. All of it was held reasonable, and the 4 hours 18 minutes recorded were allowed at the agreed rate of £324 per hour, in the sum of £1,671.84 including VAT [44]. Interest at 8% above base rate was consistent with the Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998 and entirely usual and reasonable [45].

Summary judgment was granted for the fees to the decision, for all time reasonably expended pursuing recovery since the decision (£5,093.28 to the application and £1,671.84 since, each including VAT), for interest and for costs [47].

On costs, the Claimants claimed the full amount of their legal costs, to which they were entitled under the contract. Their statement of costs totalled £37,664.30, and VAT had properly not been claimed on the professional legal costs [48].

The judge awarded the sums claimed. Although the Claimants were contractually entitled to them, she would not have reduced them in any event: in the circumstances they were reasonably incurred and reasonable in amount. She accepted they were possibly higher than they might have been, which in large part appeared to result from the extra work needed to address the Defendant’s unmeritorious and wide-ranging submissions [49].

Practical Implications

This is a first instance decision on a summary judgment application. It shows that clause 4(b) style wording, entitling an adjudicator to the full amount of his administrative, legal and other costs of recovering unpaid invoices, brings pursuit time and legal fees within the contractual debt rather than leaving them to be argued separately [44], [48].

Adjudicators should keep contemporaneous timesheets for post-decision work, as well as for the reference itself, with an explanation of each task. That evidence, together with the agreed hourly rate, underpinned the award of pursuit time [44]. Claimants should also be ready to show that legal costs were reasonably incurred and reasonable in amount, since the judge considered that question despite the contractual entitlement [49].

For a party resisting a claim for adjudicator fees, complaints about jurisdiction, natural justice or the merits of the decision are unlikely to assist where the terms provide for payment regardless of enforceability [34]. A challenge to the hours needs particulars and a positive case on what time would have been reasonable [18], [41].

Conceding that the hours were worked while calling them excessive, with no positive case on what time would have been reasonable, was held wholly inadequate [41]. Defendants should also weigh that wide-ranging, unmeritorious submissions can increase the legal costs they ultimately pay under such terms [49].

▶ Watch the case summary

Recovery Of Costs Pursuant To A Contractual Entitlement

Summary Assessment Without Opposition | Court Applies Independent Scrutiny to Unopposed Costs Claims

Summary Assessment Reduced by 20% On Broad-Brush Proportionality Grounds Despite Rejecting Specific Challenges

Court Declines To Order Further N260 Breakdown | Broad Brush Applies On Summary Assessment | High Travel Figure Still Counts

The Correct Approach To Summary Assessment | Guideline Hourly Rates Up By 35%?