Damages Award Does Not Automatically Make A Party The Winner | High Court Upholds No Order As To Costs In Boundary Dispute

A damages award does not by itself make a party the successful party under CPR 44.2; where non-monetary relief such as a declaration or injunction was sought and refused, the court assesses who has won in substance and reality across the overall outcome.

boundary dispute
In Mary Egan v Neil Morgan & Anor [2026] EWHC 2946 (BP), the High Court, Mr Justice Tappin, dismissed an appeal against a no order as to costs decision after a boundary dispute trial in which the claim and counterclaim were intermixed. The appellant recovered damages, including aggravated damages and damages in lieu of an injunction, and defeated the respondents’ damages claim. She failed, however, to obtain the boundary declaration she sought as her primary case and the injunction she had pursued. The trial judge was entitled to consider the overall outcome, including non-monetary relief, and to find no overall winner. It was not right to focus only on financial remedies while ignoring the failure to obtain non-financial relief sought. Practitioners assessing success under CPR 44.2 should weigh declarations and injunctions sought and refused, because the court asks who, in substance and reality, has won.

[24] As the Judge said in paragraph 90(vii)(d) of the CJ, the Appellant decided to fight the case on the basis that the boundary was in the Hedge and that she could choose what (if any) fence existed on her side of it. Nor do I agree that the Judge was wrong to have regard to the non-monetary value to the Respondents of succeeding in defeating the Appellant’s claim that the boundary was in the middle of the Hedge (which would have required them to have placed any animal-proof fence in their garden to the west of the Hedge). It is not surprising that in paragraph 90(i) of the CJ the Judge described the location of the boundary as being the most important point of all. In a case such as this, which is not purely about monetary remedies, the Judge was right (and certainly not wrong in the sense explained in the authorities) to have regard to outcomes relating to non-monetary relief such as the declaration sought by the Appellant.

Citations

Atlasjet v Kupeli [2018] EWCA Civ 1264 Cited by the Recorder, in the passage quoted in this judgment, for the proposition that the court should consider the overall outcome of the litigation and the issues within it, including outcomes regarding non-monetary relief.

Roache v News Group [1998] EMLR 161 Cited for the requirement to look closely at the facts and ask who, as a matter of substance and reality, has won; the Respondents also relied on it for the point that an appeal court must not interfere merely because it would have exercised the discretion differently.

Day v Day [2006] EWCA Civ 415 Relied on by the Appellant in support of her submission that the Respondents, who had to pay damages, were the parties writing the cheque.

F&C Alternative Investments v Barthelemy [2012] EWCA Civ 843 Cited for the proposition that an appellate court may only interfere with a costs decision after trial if it is wrong in principle, takes into account or omits a relevant matter, or is plainly unsustainable.

Widlake v BAA [2009] EWCA Civ 1256 Cited with Walsh v Singh for the proposition that conduct is principally considered for its causative effect on increased costs, but misconduct may be so egregious as to attract a proportionate costs penalty regardless of causative effect.

Walsh v Singh [2011] EWCA Civ 80 Cited with Widlake v BAA for the same two-limb approach to the relevance of conduct to costs.

Key Points

  • Where a claim and counterclaim are intermixed and the case is not purely about monetary remedies, the court may assess success under CPR 44.2 by reference to the overall outcome, including outcomes relating to non-monetary relief such as a declaration sought and refused. [23, 24]
  • It is not right to focus only on the financial remedies granted or refused and to ignore a party’s failure to obtain the non-financial relief it sought, so recovering damages does not of itself make a party the successful party. [23]
  • The court looks closely at the facts and asks who, as a matter of substance and reality, has won. [26]
  • A party’s pre-action correspondence, pleading and maintenance of its primary case at trial can show how important a failed head of relief was to it when success is assessed. [24]
  • An award of damages in lieu of an injunction does not make the refusal of the injunction irrelevant where the party strenuously sought the injunction and the outcome was of real value to the opponent. [25]

[25] “Thirdly, I do not agree that the Judge was wrong to have regard to the fact that an injunction was refused in respect of Fence 3. As can be seen from paragraphs 201 et seq of the SJ, the Appellant strenuously contended for an injunction in respect of Fence 3 and resisted the suggestion that it should become the boundary with damages paid in lieu. As can be seen from the Judge’s reasoning on this issue, his conclusion that Fence 3 should be the boundary between the properties was of real value to the Respondents.”

Key Findings In The Case

  • The Recorder’s conclusion that the litigation was something of a score draw, with no overall winner, disclosed no error of the type permitting an appeal court to intervene. [22, 26]
  • The Recorder did consider the pleaded issues and the remedies granted, and it was not right to focus only on financial remedies while ignoring the Appellant’s failure to obtain the non-financial relief she sought. [23]
  • The Recorder was entitled to give weight to the Appellant’s failure on her case that the boundary was the middle of the Hedge, which was the core of her pleaded case, and to the non-monetary value to the Respondents of defeating it. [24]
  • The Recorder was entitled to have regard to the refusal of an injunction in respect of Fence 3, notwithstanding the award of damages in lieu, because the Appellant had strenuously sought the injunction and the outcome was of real value to the Respondents. [25]
  • Ground 1 was rejected and, with the conduct grounds also failing, the appeal was dismissed. [27, 41]

[26] “Ultimately it was necessary for the Judge to look closely at the facts of the case before him and ask who, as a matter of substance and reality, has won (see Roache v News Group). That is what he did, and for the reasons I have explained it is not possible for an appeal court to say that he was wrong in his assessment that there was no overall winner.”

In Mary Egan v Neil Morgan & Anor [2026] EWHC 2946 (BP), the High Court upheld a no order as to costs decision after a boundary trial. The Appellant recovered damages but lost the declaration and injunction she had pursued. Identifying the successful party under CPR 44.2 required a look at the overall outcome, including non-monetary relief, so practitioners framing costs arguments after mixed results should not rely on a damages award alone.

Background

The dispute concerned approximately 45 square metres of land along a boundary of approximately 60 metres, of extremely limited (if any) usable or other value [1]. The Respondents claimed damages for the Appellant’s removal of Fence 2. She counterclaimed for a declaration that the boundary was the middle of the Hedge, alternative declarations, an injunction requiring removal of Fence 3, an order prohibiting trespass, and damages [11], [12].

Recorder Dagnall held that the boundary was Fence 0, a line for which neither party had contended [14], [18]. Parts of Fences 2 and 3 trespassed. He awarded the Appellant £1300 damages and £1300 aggravated damages and rejected the Respondents’ damages claim [14]. He refused an injunction, awarded £3250 in lieu and declared the line of Fence 3 the boundary [15]. He then made no order as to the costs of the proceedings, subject to other orders [2].

Costs Issues Before the Court

The Appellant sought to replace the costs order with an order that the Respondents pay her costs on the indemnity basis [3]. Under Ground 1, for which Richards J granted permission, the question was whether the Recorder erred in concluding that the litigation had been a score draw, and should instead have concluded that the Appellant was the successful party [4], [17]. The appeal was brought on the footing that the decision was wrong within CPR 52.21(3)(a) [7].

The Parties’ Positions

Daniel Petrides appeared for the Appellant; Neil Morgan appeared in person for the Respondents. The Appellant advanced three criticisms. First, success should be determined by the pleaded issues and the remedies granted. Because her damages claim succeeded, including damages in lieu of an injunction, and the Respondents’ claim failed, she said she was plainly the winner. She relied on the Recorder’s own finding that she was more, although not wholly, successful on remedies and damages [19].

Secondly, she said her failure on the Hedge boundary did not matter. What mattered was whether Fences 2 and 3 stood on her land, and the Respondents were the parties writing the cheque, relying on Day v Day [20]. She also said reliance on the subjective value to the Respondents was wrong in principle. Thirdly, the refusal of an injunction was irrelevant because she obtained damages in lieu [21].

The Court’s Decision

The Recorder’s reasoning is set out at [18]. He declined to divide up the claim and the counterclaim or to adopt an approach based simply on who wrote out the cheque. The matters were inter-mixed, all concerning the location of the boundary and the lawfulness of operations relating to the fences. Relying on Atlasjet v Kupeli, he considered the overall outcome, including outcomes on non-monetary relief.

He found the Respondents more, but not wholly, successful on the boundary. The Appellant was more, although not wholly, successful on remedies, damages and determinations as to previous wrongful conduct. He therefore saw the outcome as something of a score draw, with neither party successful or unsuccessful in overall CPR 44.2 terms [18].

Mr Justice Tappin found no error of the type that would permit an appeal court to intervene [22]. The Recorder had considered matters by reference to the pleaded issues and the remedies granted. Nor was it right to focus only on the financial remedies granted or refused while ignoring the Appellant’s failure to obtain the non-financial relief she sought [23]. A damages award therefore did not settle who was the successful party.

The failed Hedge case was a legitimate consideration. It had been the Appellant’s case in pre-action correspondence, the core of her pleaded case and the subject of a declaration she sought. She maintained it even after the evidence of Fence 0 emerged. Had she cared only whether the fences were on her land, she would have been content to agree a boundary along Fence 1, or Fence 0 [24].

The judge also accepted the relevance of the non-monetary value to the Respondents of defeating that claim, which would have required them to place any animal-proof fence in their garden. Mr Justice Tappin said: “In a case such as this, which is not purely about monetary remedies, the Judge was right (and certainly not wrong in the sense explained in the authorities) to have regard to outcomes relating to non-monetary relief such as the declaration sought by the Appellant.” [24]

The damages in lieu point was answered by the way the Appellant had run her case. She strenuously contended for an injunction in respect of Fence 3 and resisted the suggestion that it should become the boundary with damages paid in lieu. The Recorder’s conclusion that Fence 3 should be the boundary was of real value to the Respondents [25]. The award of damages in lieu did not make the refusal of the injunction irrelevant.

Ultimately, the Recorder had to look closely at the facts and ask who, as a matter of substance and reality, had won, citing Roache v News Group. He had done so, and it was not possible for an appeal court to say that he was wrong in his assessment that there was no overall winner [26]. Ground 1 was rejected [27], and the appeal was dismissed [41].

Practical Implications

The decision is that of a single High Court judge on appeal from the County Court, applying the discretion under CPR 44.2. For a party seeking costs after a mixed result, a damages award is not a complete answer. In a case that is not purely about monetary remedies, the court may weigh declarations and injunctions sought and refused, and their value to the opponent, even where that value is mainly subjective rather than financial [18], [24].

Those acting for a party who defeats primary non-monetary relief should identify that relief in costs submissions and explain its value to the client. Equally, those acting for the party recovering damages should anticipate that a failed declaration or injunction may be set against the money awarded when the court identifies the successful party [23], [25].

Pre-action correspondence and pleadings will be read to establish what each party treated as central, as they were here [24]. Solicitors advising on strategy should note that persisting with a primary case after the evidence undermines it was treated as showing its importance to the party, and its failure counted in the overall assessment of who, in substance and reality, won [24], [26].

▶ Watch the case summary

No Order As To Costs Where Neither Party Is The “Successful Party” | Matrix v Musst

Who Was The Successful Party? | Costs Order Following Mixed Appeal Outcome

Appeal Costs Follow Event But No Costs Ordered For Mixed-Outcome Hearing Below

CPR 44.2(6)(f) | Costs In The Case Where Interwoven Issues And No Clear Winner Precludes Issue-Based Or Percentage Orders

And The Winner Is? Defendant Who Beat Both Strike Out and Summary Judgment Recovers 75% of Her Costs After 80% Costs Order Against Her Reversed on Appeal

Issues Based And Proportional Costs Orders: When Should They Be Made?