High Court Cuts Grade A Rates Exceeding Guideline Rates | Proportionality Further Reduces Summarily Assessed Costs

Where counsel is substantially involved, Grade A rates above the Guideline Rates for the relevant band may be reduced on summary assessment. A proportionality check of the resulting total is then applied separately, with the paying party’s own contribution to costs taken into account.

Pound sign with downward arrow
In Adrian Hyde v Edward Magan [2026] EWHC 2955 (BP), the judge, Mrs Justice Rushton, summarily assessed on the standard basis the costs of a successful half-day insolvency appeal and the hearings below, claimed at £57,756.81, at £35,000 including VAT. She found the hours reasonable but declined to allow Grade A partner or senior associate rates of £735 and £579 against the paying party, given the substantial involvement of counsel and because those rates exceeded the Guideline Rates for a Band 2 London firm. Her line-by-line figures totalled £46,284.41, which she reduced to £35,000 by reference to proportionality. She accepted that the paying party’s point had some force, while noting that his approach to the litigation had increased costs to some degree. Receiving parties should be ready to justify Grade A rates above guideline where counsel is substantially involved, and should expect a separate proportionality check of the total.

[110] Most of the solicitors’ costs are claimed at a Grade A partner’s/senior associate’s hourly rate of £735 for the earlier costs and £579 for the later costs. While the TIB may have wanted the attendance of a partner or senior associate to this matter, I do not consider it is reasonable to allow costs at such a rate as against the other side, given the substantial involvement of counsel. In any event, those rates exceed the Guideline Rates for a Band 2 London firm for a Grade A solicitor, for both periods. The number of hours claimed are however reasonable.

Key Points

  • On an appeal lasting less than a day, summary assessment is the usual approach, and the court may decide the costs issues on written submissions where costs statements have been filed and the paying party has had a good opportunity to address quantum, to avoid the costs of a further hearing or of detailed assessment. [106, 108]
  • The substantial involvement of counsel may make it unreasonable to recover Grade A partner or senior associate rates from the paying party, even where the client wanted a senior fee earner to attend. [110]
  • Hourly rates above the Guideline Rates for the relevant band and grade may be reduced even where the hours claimed are accepted as reasonable. [110]
  • After assessing the items claimed, the court may make a further reduction of the overall total by reference to proportionality, and in doing so may weigh the paying party’s own contribution to the level of costs. [111, 114, 115]

[111] “On the costs schedule for the earlier hearing, I would therefore have allowed a total of £8,000 plus VAT for solicitors’ costs, and counsel’s fees in full, subject to what I say below about proportionality. That would be a total of £16,680 including VAT. [112] On the costs schedule for the Appeal, I would have allowed £12,500 plus VAT for solicitors’ costs.”

Key Findings In The Case

  • Mr Magan was ordered to pay Mr Hyde’s costs of the Appeal and below, summarily assessed on the standard basis at £35,000 in total including any VAT, against a claimed total of £57,756.81. [104, 108, 116]
  • Grade A rates of £735 and £579 were not reasonable as against Mr Magan given the substantial involvement of counsel, and in any event exceeded the Guideline Rates for a Band 2 London firm for both periods; the hours claimed were reasonable. [110]
  • Before proportionality, the costs would have been allowed at £16,680 including VAT for the earlier hearings and £29,604.41 for the Appeal, totalling £46,284.41, with counsel’s fee for work on the papers and conference reduced to £4,000. [111, 112, 113]
  • Mr Magan’s proportionality point had some force, although his approach to the litigation had increased costs to some degree, and the total allowed was reduced to £35,000 payable in 21 days. [114, 115]
  • There were no grounds for displacing the usual order that the unsuccessful party pays, and the costs issues were decided on written submissions without the short oral hearing Mr Magan requested. [104, 106, 107]

[113] “The two figures together would total £46,284.41. [114] However, I also consider that the point made about proportionality by Mr Magan has some force, although I also bear in mind that his approach to the litigation, in referring to many extraneous matters, has undoubtedly increased costs at least to some degree. [115] Overall, by reference to proportionality, I will therefore reduce the total costs allowed to £35,000. Payment will be ordered to be made in 21 days.”

In Adrian Hyde v Edward Magan [2026] EWHC 2955 (BP), the High Court carried out a summary assessment of the costs of a half day appeal and the hearings below in two stages: a reasonableness review that cut Grade A rates above the Guideline Rates, followed by a proportionality reduction of the resulting total. It shows how a reasonable item-by-item figure can still be reduced overall.

Background

Mr Hyde, the trustee in bankruptcy of Lord Magan, appealed against a decision setting aside a statutory demand for £46,791 served on Mr Magan [1], [2]. The Debt was an order for indemnity costs made against Mr Magan following Mr Hyde’s successful application for delivery up of documents [4]. After a half day hearing at which Mr Magan represented himself, the appeal was allowed and the Set Aside Application dismissed [99].

After circulating the judgment on an embargoed basis, Mrs Justice Rushton invited submissions on costs as to principle, basis of assessment and quantum [103]. The claimed total was £57,756.81 [104]. The costs claimed of the underlying hearings totalled £22,652 and the costs claimed of the Appeal totalled £35,104.81 [109].

Costs Issues Before the Court

The judge had to decide who should pay the costs of the Appeal and below, whether to assess them summarily or send them to detailed assessment, and whether to decide those questions on paper despite Mr Magan’s request for a short oral hearing. On quantum, the issues were the solicitors’ Grade A hourly rates, including for travel and waiting time, counsel’s fees for the appeal, and whether the total was proportionate to the underlying debt [104].

The Parties’ Positions

For Mr Hyde, Mr Groves submitted that there was no reason to depart from the usual order under CPR 44.2 and that the costs should cover both the appeal and the hearings below. He contended that summary assessment was appropriate; failing that, he sought detailed assessment with a payment on account, proposed at 60% and later reduced to 40% [104].

Mr Magan, acting as a litigant in person, accepted the ordinary starting point but invited the court to consider no order as to some or all of the Appeal costs, or detailed assessment. He challenged the full Grade A rate, including for travel and waiting time, and counsel’s fees of £5,500 and £7,500 plus VAT. He argued that the total costs exceeded the underlying debt, which was material to reasonableness and proportionality [104].

The Court’s Decision

On principle, Mr Hyde was the successful party and there were no grounds for displacing the usual order; Mr Magan was ordered to pay the costs of the Appeal and below [107]. The judge decided the costs issues on the written submissions alone. She considered this to be in the interests of both parties and the efficient administration of justice, and a way to avoid the costs of a further hearing or of detailed assessment [106].

She proceeded to summary assessment. That was the usual approach on an appeal of less than a day; costs statements had been filed, and Mr Magan had had a good opportunity to make submissions on quantum, which he had done. The assessment was made on the standard basis [108].

The first stage addressed the solicitors’ rates. Most of the solicitors’ time was claimed at a Grade A rate of £735 for the earlier costs and £579 for the later costs. Mrs Justice Rushton gave two reasons for not allowing those rates against Mr Magan. The first was the substantial involvement of counsel, even if the trustee had wanted a partner or senior associate to attend. The second was that the rates exceeded the Guideline Rates for a Band 2 London firm for a Grade A solicitor, for both periods [110].

The hours were not cut. The judge said: “The number of hours claimed are however reasonable.” The reduction therefore operated on rate alone. The judgment does not state the substituted hourly rate; it gives only the resulting totals for solicitors’ costs on each schedule [110].

On the schedule for the earlier hearings, she would have allowed £8,000 plus VAT for solicitors’ costs against £12,960 claimed, and counsel’s fees in full, expressly subject to proportionality. That came to £16,680 including VAT [109], [111].

On the Appeal schedule, she would have allowed £12,500 plus VAT for solicitors’ costs against £15,583.80 claimed. Counsel’s brief fee of £7,500 was allowed, but the fee for advice in conference and settling the Appeal documents, claimed at £5,500, was reduced to £4,000. With disbursements, the Appeal figure was £29,604.41 [109], [112]. The two figures together totalled £46,284.41 [113].

The second stage was proportionality. Mrs Justice Rushton accepted that Mr Magan’s point about proportionality had “some force”. She also bore in mind that his approach to the litigation, in referring to many extraneous matters, had increased costs at least to some degree [114]. His own conduct therefore tempered, but did not prevent, a reduction.

Overall, by reference to proportionality, she reduced the total costs allowed to £35,000, payable in 21 days [115]. The order was for the costs of the Appeal and below, summarily assessed at £35,000 in total, including any VAT [116]. The proportionality reduction was applied to the combined total of both schedules rather than item by item, and the judgment gives no breakdown of the £35,000.

Practical Implications

Receiving parties claiming Grade A rates above the Guideline Rates should be ready to justify both the grade and the rate where counsel is substantially involved. The judgment treated counsel’s involvement as a reason in its own right, separate from the guideline comparison, for refusing partner or senior associate rates against the paying party.

Paying parties should challenge rate and grade separately from hours. Here the hours were accepted as reasonable, yet the rate challenge succeeded. The paying party should also put proportionality squarely, comparing the total claimed with the sums in issue: Mr Magan’s point that the total costs exceeded the underlying debt was found to have some force.

Receiving parties should note that a paying party’s own approach to the litigation can be weighed against a proportionality argument, though here it reduced rather than removed the deduction. On a summary assessment after a short appeal, written submissions on costs may be the only opportunity a party gets. Detailed points on quantum, including counsel’s fees and travel and waiting time, belong in those submissions rather than being held back for an oral hearing that may not be granted.

▶ Watch the case summary

Summary Assessment Reduced by 20% On Broad-Brush Proportionality Grounds Despite Rejecting Specific Challenges

The Correct Approach To Summary Assessment | Guideline Hourly Rates Up By 35%?

Impact Of Counsel Involvment On Hourly Rates

CILEX Fee Earners With Over Eight Years’ Experience Fall Within Grade A | Above-Guideline Rates Can Still Attract A Reduction

Costs Judge Rejects Mathematical Approach To Proportionality Assessment | Stockler [2025] EWHC 2262

How Relevant Are The Guideline Hourly Rates?